Thanks to Master Cat! Ben Frahm for this breakdown that was certain to include the “All Is Lost” beat (but does not include a B Story):
Written and Directed by: J.C. Chandor
Genre: Dude with a Problem: Innocent Hero, Sudden Event, Life-or-Death Battle
Sub-Genre: Nature Problem
The remains of a capsized boat float in the ocean.
Set-Up: Via narration (Robert Redford VO) we learn:
– A Man has been on a boat for eight days.
– He’s in the middle of the ocean.
– He’s alone.
– And per the tone of his voice, he doesn’t think he’s going to survive.
“I tried, I tried… I fought ‘til the end, I’m not sure what that is worth, but know that I did.”
INSERT: “EIGHT DAYS EARLIER”
– Our Man (Redford) wakes up. He’s on a boat. And water seeps into the cabin.
– Further investigation reveals a hole in the boat.
— What should he do? What are the implications and severity of this problem? Our hero must act quickly…
– He discovers that his boat must have sailed into a corrugated metal shipping container and this is what caused the gaping hole.
– Our Man uses a flotation device with ropes to dislodge his boat away from the metal container.
– And acting with skill and grace…
Break into Two:
…He repairs the hole.
Fun and Games: A Story and Second Act Goal: simply to survive and get help.
– The Man rescues a radio from the cabin. It’s wet with salt water and currently doesn’t work. He cleans the device with fresh water. And now must let it dry.
– A skilled sailor, Our Man wastes no time. He checks the repaired hole in the boat.
– Empties water from the cabin.
– Recovers food and drink to keep healthy and strong.
– And the next day, to his surprise the radio works. Or at least starts to work. A signal comes through and then quickly dies.
– Our man climbs the mast of the boat and tries to reconnect the electrical wires, hoping this will help. But it doesn’t…
– And looking in the distance, he notices a significant storm is now heading his way…
– The storm comes that night.
– The weather and conditions are so severe that the boat capsizes.
– Our Man is tossed into the ocean. His head damaged. And now his only means of survival has been compromised.
Bad Guys Close In:
– Groggy and discombobulated from his head injury, Our Man gathers the energy to prepare the lifeboat and uses this to barely escape the storm.
– The next day, he returns to his demolished boat and recovers necessities. An emergency kit. Some personal belongings. Water. Medical supplies to fix his head. And a map and navigation device in order to determine his coordinates.
– Our Man realizes that he’s just south of a shipping route. And that if the ocean currents continue, he will pass through the route and hopefully be noticed and rescued by passing boats.
– However, in the meantime, he must endure another storm…
– … which passes through and capsizes his lifeboat.
– Some of his possessions are lost. And the next day, he realizes that his only fresh water supply has been contaminated with salt water.
– Staying calm and collected, Our Man refuses to give up. Instead, he constructs a device to allow water condensation to be collected into a cup. This actually works and Our Man is able to drink some fresh water, albeit a very small amount.
– He checks the coordinates again on the map and realizes he’s currently in the shipping route.
– And sure enough, later that day, a cargo boat appears. Our Man frantically tries to signal for help using a flare from the emergency kit but this doesn’t work. The cargo ship never sees him and doesn’t stop to help.
– The next day, another boat appears. Our Man won’t let this one get away. And lights all of his flares, hoping to be noticed.
– But the result is the same. The boat doesn’t see him and passes right by.
– Our Man checks the map and realizes that he’s floated out of the “shipping route,” so his chances of encountering another boat are unlikely.
– He’s out of flares.
– He has no food or water.
– And it appears that Our Man is giving up.
– He writes a letter to his loved ones (most likely the one read as narration at the beginning of the film). And puts the letter in a jar and throws it into the water.
– It’s getting dark, and when Our Man lies down and appears to be completely giving up… he notices a light in the distance.
– On the horizon, there is potentially another boat.
– But he realizes he doesn’t have any flares left.
– So instead he lights some papers and manuals from the lifeboat on fire, a last resort of being discovered…
– However, the fire spreads… and quickly engulfs the life boat…
All Is Lost:
The lifeboat burns and Our Man is forced into the ocean…
Dark Night of the Soul:
– Without a boat…
– Without hope of rescue…
– Our Man gives up. He lets himself sink towards the bottom of the ocean…
– Staring at the still burning lifeboat on the water’s surface…
– We are convinced Our Man will die…
– Until, at the last moment, another light is noticed.
– It appears to be a rescue boat—that must have noticed Our Man’s burning lifeboat.
– The boat light approaches… — And just when it looks like Our Man is sinking into the abyss…
– He starts swimming towards the surface…
Break into Three:
Our Man refuses to die and using whatever energy he has left… frantically swims to the surface…
– Struggling for breath and life, Our Man does everything he can to swim to the boat.
– This is his last chance of survival…
– And to our surprise, when Our Man reaches the surface…
… A HAND appears from the boat and grabs Our Man’s hand.
We QUICKLY FADE TO WHITE.
[Editor Note: There is a spirited debate in the film community: Does Our Man truly survive... or has he accepted death? What do you think?]